Email marketing is still one of the most potent tools in restaurant marketing or marketing in any other industry. The return offered by email marketing exceeds that of any other strategy in your business arsenal despite changes that have negatively impacted open rates (see image below). That’s because email marketing provides direct access to your customers’ inboxes and allows for personalized, targeted communications that have a more significant impact on purchase intentions. Unlike social media, which depends on algorithms to reach audiences, email marketing ensures that your message reaches subscribers. This channel provides restaurants with a low-cost avenue to build a loyal customer base that supports retention and revisits. The big secret is using it correctly and that’s what we aim to show you in this post.

How to build a loyal customer base
Get to know your customers
Before you dive into writing email messages, it’s super important to know who your customers are, what problems they face, and what they’re really like. Are you dealing with families who need kid-friendly menus or busy professionals looking for a quick lunch? You can glean some of this information from loyalty sign-ups or feedback forms or even by collecting business cards from patrons. These tools can help you build a subscriber list and separate that list by customer type.
By grouping your patrons by demographic or lifestyle elements, you can make your email messages more relevant and increase the chances they’ll respond to your content. The good news is that there are plenty of modern restaurant loyalty software options available to help you sort and analyze all this information so that you can create targeted email campaigns like a pro.
Build your email list
Every solid email marketing campaign starts with a great email list. Laws in the US, EU, and Britain make it illegal to purchase, rent, or borrow subscriber lists from third-party providers and include stiff penalties for each violation. Thus, you must expend effort to gather your own list of subscribers by offering an incentive in exchange for patrons’ email addresses.
In building your list, you should focus on gathering quality leads both in your restaurant and online. Offer those who sign up a little incentive, like a discount on their next order, exclusive updates on new menu items, or maybe even something free on their next visit. Contests are a great way to gather subscribers legally, and offering the chance at a bigger prize goes a long way toward encouraging participation. Make sure you have easy sign-up prompts on your website and social media—even use a QR code on table tents to gather the most subscribers possible! Simplifying the sign-up process will encourage more people to join in. Don’t try to collect too much information from subscribers, or you’ll find fewer people willing to fill out the form.
Also, spend the effort to clean your list over time. Although it sounds counterintuitive to eliminate subscribers, it’s a good practice to remove those who don’t open or engage with your brand after several messages. Remember, even a small but engaged list is way better than a big list of folks who aren’t really interested.
Write good content
Your email campaigns should be about more than just deals and discounts. To build a loyal customer base, add some fun, entertaining, informative, or engaging content. Share remarkable stories about your chefs, where you get your ingredients, how to reheat that doggie bag, or anything that helps your audience identify with your brand. Let them know about new menu changes or events they won’t want to miss. Toss in some helpful stuff, like recipe ideas or pairing tips; this not only builds your authority but keeps your restaurant fresh in their minds.
Your content should encourage subscribers to read the message. That begins with an enticing subject line that’s personalized for the individual. Include images and lots of white space as you write. Keep your messages short. It’s better to send out messages more frequently than to pack messages with a ton of text.
Increasingly, consumers want to support brands that align with their values, as you can see below. Use your email marketing campaigns to show you care about your community or support causes your customers care about. For instance, you might send your staff to help out at a local soup kitchen or package meals to go to those walloped by a natural disaster.

Making it personal
Generic emails? No thanks! They won’t win over your subscribers. Personalization is key to making your emails feel unique and timely for each customer. Use your data wisely by addressing customers by name. But, you need to go beyond this to use deep personalization, such as suggesting menu items based on their previous orders. For instance, if a subscriber always goes for seafood, sending them an email highlighting new seafood specials makes them feel valued and understood. Capture subscribers’ information, such as birthdays and anniversaries, so you can send email messages containing special deals just for them to celebrate these milestones.
Timing is everything
Timing can seriously make or break your email marketing strategy. Pay attention to your customers and send messages at times when they’re most likely to respond. For happy hour promos, it’s best to hit them up late morning or early afternoon when they’re daydreaming about their evening plans. A weekend brunch announcement might get better traction if sent out mid-week. Keep the momentum going by sticking to a consistent schedule, and don’t forget to consider seasonal or local events that might influence your customers’ plans, like holidays or festivals. Adjusting your email timing around these can boost engagement even further.
Rewards for loyalty
Email marketing really shines when you pair it with a loyalty program when you’re trying to build a loyal customer base. Use email messages to show your customers how close they are to earning complimentary appetizers or discounts on their subsequent visits. Regular updates about their loyalty points keep them interested and connected to your restaurant. Think about offering “double points” days or in-store loyalty perks to encourage repeat visits. By linking your email campaigns with your loyalty program, you create a cycle of value and engagement that keeps customers coming back for more.
Stay alert to everything
No email marketing strategy is complete without keeping tabs on how well it’s performing. Watch metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates to see what’s working and what’s not. Try A/B testing to figure out which subject lines, images, and calls-to-action resonate best with your audience. Use the feedback to keep refining your approach for the best possible results. Tracking what customers do after they get your emails, like redeeming offers or visiting your restaurant, will show how effective your campaigns are at driving action. You can then use these insights to create more targeted and impactful strategies that align with what your customers want.
Long-term gains
It’s not just today’s sales that make email marketing a good investment; it’s about building a loyal customer base that feels connected to your restaurant. Regularly sending out valuable and meaningful emails builds trust and keeps your brand front and center in their minds. You can bet that loyal customers will spread the word about your restaurant to their friends and family, leading to organic growth through word-of-mouth. The long-term engagement will bring you lasting profitability and stability in your restaurant business.
Conclusion
In the competitive world of restaurants, keeping loyal customers is just as important as bringing in new ones. Email marketing is one of the best ways to nurture your relationships with diners, helping turn casual visitors into lifelong fans. By knowing your audience, creating personal and engaging content, and tying in your loyalty program, email marketing can become a significant part of your restaurant’s success. Get started today and see how a well-crafted email campaign can transform your business!
Need marketing help to support business growth?
We welcome the opportunity to show you how we can make your marketing SIZZLE with our data-driven, results-oriented marketing strategies. Sign up for our FREE newsletter, get our FREE guide to creating an awesome website, or contact us for more information on hiring us.
Hausman and Associates, the publisher of MKT Maven, is a full-service marketing agency operating at the intersection of marketing and digital media. Check out our full range of services.
Discover more from MKT Maven
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
logo